Your Cart

Aidan Questions? Call Aidan 800-460-5810

Your cart is empty

Best Well Water Test Kit (2026)

Aidan Walsh
Aidan Walsh 32 years in water treatment
This is my direct line: no bots, no AI, no call center. You reach me, the same person who wrote this guide, 8 AM to 5 PM Eastern, every day.

Number copied. Text it from your phone: 443-277-2204.

People call me all the time asking what the most accurate test is for their well. It's an independent lab test that you fill at your own tap and mail back. Ours is $199 and covers 53 items, bacteria included. Tap Score's $209 Essential Well Water Test runs the same 53 lab items, and I'll tell you why up front: SimpleLab, the company behind Tap Score, runs the lab work for our kit too. Below is how ours, Tap Score's and WaterCheck's compare, what the strips from the hardware store can and can't tell you, and when you don't need to buy a kit at all.

Hands holding our well water test kit's padded return pouch, with the sample bottles and paperwork on the table

Caller "If they order a test from there, like they have an advanced test for like four hundred bucks or something. If they do that, you guys could recommend, I guess, basically the same thing based on that test result as well?"

Aidan

Aidan "Yeah, all the lab tests are pretty much the same."

A home buyer in Virginia, September 2026, asking whether a Tap Score report would work instead of ours. This page is the long version of that answer.

Quick Answer

The best well water test kit is a mail-in lab test that reports bacteria, metals and the water chemistry from one sample.

  1. Ours or Tap Score's Essential. Our $199 kit runs the same 53 lab items as Tap Score's $209 Essential Well Water Test, through the same SimpleLab lab network. Tap Score adds a hydrogen sulfide strip you read at home. See who runs the lab behind each kit.
  2. Strips for a quick check. Hardware-store strips read pH, hardness and iron close enough for a quick look, but they give you a color, not a number, and they don't read bacteria. Coliform bacteria came back present on about 4 in 10 of the well tests my customers sent in since August (183 of 462). See are hardware-store strips good enough.
  3. WaterCheck. WaterCheck's $220 Basic covers 36 items, bacteria included, at National Testing Laboratories' own lab, and the return shipping is on you. See the comparison table.
  4. Test every year. The EPA says to test a private well every year for total coliform bacteria, nitrate, total dissolved solids and pH. See what a well test should cover.

Our well water test is $199 with a prepaid overnight FedEx return label, and I go over the results with you when you send them to me.

Which well water test kit is best?

For most private wells, the best kit is a 53-item mail-in lab test with bacteria: ours at $199 or Tap Score's Essential at $209. I'd pick ours, and not only because it's $10 less: you also get a results page that puts each number next to its EPA limit, and me on the phone to go over it. If you'd rather have Tap Score's report and their support team, the lab work is the same.

Kit Price What it tests Return shipping Results Who goes over it with you
Our well water test $199 53 items: coliform and E. coli, 25 metals (lead, arsenic, uranium, iron, manganese and more), nitrate, hardness, pH, dissolved solids Prepaid overnight FedEx label About 5 business days after the lab gets it I go over it by phone or text when you send it to me; our results page also shows each EPA limit
Tap Score Essential $209 The same 53 lab items, plus a hydrogen sulfide strip you read at home Prepaid label 5 business days at the lab Tap Score's support team, by chat, phone or email; the report includes treatment recommendations
Tap Score Advanced $399 114 items: the Essential list plus 50 volatile and semi-volatile organic compounds, 7 petroleum compounds and 2 pesticides Prepaid overnight label 5 business days at the lab Tap Score's support team, same as the Essential
WaterCheck Basic $220 36 items: coliform and E. coli, 22 metals and minerals, 7 inorganic chemicals, 5 physical factors You pay for it, and it must ship next day About 7 business days after the lab gets it WaterCheck's lab staff, if you call them
WaterCheck Standard $255 87 items: the Basic list plus 47 volatile organic compounds and 4 trihalomethanes (chlorination byproducts) You pay for it, and it must ship next day About 7 business days or longer WaterCheck's lab staff, if you call them
Hardware-store test strips $13 to $30 pH, hardness, iron and a few others, as a color on a chart None, you read it at the sink A few minutes You, against the chart, or text me a photo of the strip next to the chart

Prices and lists are from each company's own page on October 27, 2026. Return label costs for WaterCheck and the rest of the price ladder are in what a well water test costs.

If all you need is the yearly bacteria and nitrate check, call your county health department before you buy anything. The EPA says your local health department may test private wells for free. The list by state is in where to get your water tested.

Who runs the lab behind each kit?

SimpleLab runs the lab work for our kit, and SimpleLab also sells its own kits under the Tap Score name. I want you to know that before you compare us, because the 53 lab items on our report and on Tap Score's Essential are the same list. SimpleLab sends each sample to an independent lab in its network, which has labs in all 50 states. It names Eurofins, Pace Analytical, SGS and Microbac among its partners.

  1. Ours: SimpleLab's Drinking Water Test, Level 1 + Bacteria, run at a lab in SimpleLab's network. We add the results page and the phone review.
  2. Tap Score: SimpleLab's own brand, the same network.
  3. WaterCheck: sold by National Testing Laboratories in Cleveland, Ohio, and run in its own lab.

So the lab work is not where ours and Tap Score's differ. What differs is the price, Tap Score's hydrogen sulfide strip, and who goes over the report with you: their support team, or me. Whichever kit you pick, you take the sample yourself, and ours is not sold as a state-certified test (see when you need a state-certified lab).

If a report from Tap Score or WaterCheck is already in your inbox, you don't need ours. Send me that one, and I'll read it the same way.

Are hardware-store test strips good enough?

Strips are good enough for a quick check of pH, hardness and iron, but not for bacteria, lead or arsenic. I tell people the kits from Lowe's or Home Depot are pretty accurate; we tested them against the professional test kits we used to use. What they don't do is give you a number. They give you a color to match on a chart. A lab gives you a number for almost every item (bacteria come back present or absent), and it reports lead and arsenic at the levels the EPA's limits are set on: 0.010 mg/L (10 ppb) for arsenic and 0.015 mg/L (15 ppb) for lead.

Bar chart of 462 well tests. Teal bars show hardness over 7 grains on 201 and pH under 6.5 on 39, which a pH, hardness and iron strip can screen. Blue bars show coliform on 183, lead at or over 15 ppb on 25, E. coli on 20, arsenic over 10 ppb on 13 and nitrate over 10 ppm on 8, which those strips do not read.
What came back on 462 well tests my customers sent in, August to October 2026. Tap to enlarge.

Coliform bacteria came back present on about 4 in 10 of those tests, and E. coli on 20. Coliform is not a health threat by itself; the EPA uses it as the sign that other harmful bacteria may be getting into the water. Lead was at or over 15 ppb on 25 tests and arsenic over 10 ppb on 13. A pH, hardness and iron strip reads none of those.

Where a strip is the right tool: a quick look at pH and hardness after a neutralizer goes in, between lab tests. If you're not sure what the color means, text me a photo of the strip next to the chart.

What a well test should cover

The EPA says to test a private well every year for total coliform bacteria, nitrate, total dissolved solids and pH. Our kit and Tap Score's Essential cover all four, along with the metals and the hardness you need for sizing equipment. The EPA adds that if you suspect anything else, test for that too. You can be 2 houses next to each other and have completely different water, so test your own well. The 53-item lab list does not cover these four:

If you're worried about Why the 53-item kit misses it The test to add
A rotten egg smell Hydrogen sulfide is a gas, so it has to be taken with a certain type of container A strip or color kit at the tap, or a state-certified lab; see how to test for hydrogen sulfide
Fuel or solvents reaching the well Fuel and solvent compounds (VOCs) are not among the 53 Our $329 advanced well test (see when the advanced kit is worth it)
PFAS PFAS needs its own lab method Our $349 PFAS test (14 compounds)
Radon in the water Radon is not among the 53 Our $129 radon test
Well water test kit: lab analysis of 53 items including bacteria
No lab report yet? $199, 53 items

One sample covers the EPA's yearly list

Bacteria, nitrate, dissolved solids and pH, plus the metals and hardness, run by an independent lab in SimpleLab's network. If you already have a lab report, skip this.

Prepaid overnight FedEx return label. Results about 5 business days after the lab gets the sample.

When the advanced kit is worth it

Most wells don't need the advanced test: 42 of the 47 advanced tests my customers sent in found none of the 60 extra compounds. Of the 5 that found something, 4 showed chloroform and 1 showed naphthalene. Our advanced well test is $329 for 113 items, the 53 plus 60 volatile organic compounds. Tap Score's Advanced is $399 for 114, and WaterCheck's Standard is $255 for 87, with the return shipping on you. Buy one when you have a reason to think fuel or solvents could reach your well; otherwise start with the 53.

What comes in our well test kit

The kit comes to your door with sample bottles, some already holding the preservatives the lab needs, a sample card, a plastic bag, a cold pack you freeze first, a padded return pouch and a prepaid overnight FedEx label. Take the sample on a Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday and drop it at FedEx the same day, because the bacteria sample is time sensitive. Follow the lab's sheet in the box; the steps are also in how to test well water.

Close-up photos of our well water test kit's sample bottles, cold pack, sample card, plastic sample bag and padded return pouch
What comes in the box. Freeze the cold pack before you take the sample. Tap to enlarge.

In the video I walk through the box and the sample. I call the cold pack the preservative packet there; it keeps the samples cold, and the preservatives are already in the bottles.

What happens after your results come back

You get two emails: SimpleLab's lab report, and our results page with each number next to its EPA limit. From order to results usually takes 2 to 4 weeks, counting the shipping both ways. Then send me the link, by text or a call, and I'll go over it with you: what's a problem, what's normal, and what you need or don't need. If your water is fine, I'll tell you that. If it needs equipment, I'll tell you what and in what order. That's equipment we sell, so weigh that; the report is yours to take anywhere. To read it on your own first, see how to read your well water test results.

Aidan, Mid Atlantic Water
Got your results back?

Send Aidan any lab report

Text the link to your report, ours or another lab's, and Aidan will tell you what it means and what you need, if anything.

8 AM to 5 PM Eastern, seven days a week. A real person, not a call center.

When you need a state-certified lab

If a home sale, a lender or a well permit needs the test, check what they accept before you order any mail-in kit. Ours is not sold as a state-certified test, and you take the sample yourself. Some of those tests need a state-certified lab with a documented chain of custody, and some need a certified sampler to take the sample. The EPA's own advice is to use a lab certified for drinking water testing. Your state's certified lab list and your health department are in where to get your water tested.

What buyers wrote about our kit

These are reviews from verified buyers of our well test kits, as they wrote them, newest first. The first kit review came in April 2026.

Buyer Bought What they wrote
Anonymous, Oct 2026 Verified buyer Well water test, Colorado "Tested for everything that I needed testing for"
Anonymous, Oct 2026 Verified buyer Well water test "Great to get all the info you need effort free"
Terry T., Oct 2026 Verified buyer Well water test, Missouri "Test turned out good. The shipping from you and the lab was slower and than expected. But I got results that turned out good."
Anonymous, Sep 2026 Verified buyer Well water test "In summary: 5 stars for the product, 1 star for Mid Atlantic's promised consultation, averaged to 3 stars."
Anonymous, Aug 2026 Verified buyer Well water test, Massachusetts "Very extensive test results. Benchmarking is provided but without any context or educational references."
Anonymous, Apr 2026 Verified buyer Well water test "Easy to use, instructions easy to follow. Had results in one week. Tests for 57 or so items."

Frequently asked questions

How does Tap Score work?

You order a kit from Tap Score, take the sample at your tap, and ship it back with the prepaid label. SimpleLab, the company behind Tap Score, routes it to an independent lab in its network, and the Essential well test comes back in about 5 business days at the lab with treatment recommendations. Ours goes through SimpleLab the same way; the difference is in who runs the lab behind each kit.

How much is a well water quality test?

A full mail-in lab test runs $199 for ours, $209 for Tap Score's Essential and $220 for WaterCheck's Basic plus the return shipping. Strips cost less and county tests may be free; the whole price ladder is in what a well water test costs.

How can I test my water at home?

Dip a hardware-store strip at the kitchen sink for pH, hardness and iron, or fill a mail-in lab kit at your own tap and send it back. You take the sample yourself either way; with the lab kit, the lab does the testing. The sample steps are in how to test well water.

Are well water testing kits accurate?

A lab measures almost every item and gives you a number, using EPA and Standard Methods; our panel uses 9 of them, from EPA 150.1 for pH to SM 9223 B for bacteria. A strip gives you a color on a chart. See are hardware-store strips good enough.

Aidan Walsh
About the author

Aidan Walsh

Co-owner & Residential Water Treatment Specialist, Mid Atlantic Water

Aidan Walsh has spent 32 years in residential water treatment, the first stretch of it installing and servicing well systems before Mid Atlantic Water became an online supplier. Mid Atlantic Water is a family company; every recommendation on this site is based on what actually failed in the field and what fixed it. If you have a question this page did not answer, call 800-460-5810 or text him at 443-277-2204.

Aidan answers calls and texts 8 AM to 5 PM Eastern, every day.

Number copied. Text it from your phone: 443-277-2204.

Aidan
Talk to Aidan
Real person. No bots.
Call Text